Lioness Season 4 Paramount Plus Has the Numbers, So Where Is the Renewal?
The Season 3 finale of Lioness aired September 20. It broke Paramount Plus viewership records, delivered an 88 percent critic score on Rotten Tomatoes, and ended on a cliffhanger that brought a major character back from the dead. Six weeks later, the streamer has not renewed it.
This is not the first time Paramount Plus has slow-walked a Taylor Sheridan show. Season 3 was not confirmed until October 2025, nearly a year after Season 2 wrapped. The pattern is familiar. The silence is not.
#
What the people making it are saying
Jill Wagner, who plays Bobby and serves as executive producer, has been the loudest voice in the room. In an August ScreenRant interview, she put her own money on the line.
“We’re going to get a Season 4. We will, we will,” Wagner said. “When people see what [Sheridan] wrote for the finale, we are getting a Season 4. Or I’ll pay you $100.”
She has said it more than once. At a premiere event earlier in the year, she told MovieWeb that Sheridan told her the show “will go as long as I want it to go.” She added “There’s so much to pull from. You watch the news. The world is a very interesting place right now. I think people are interested, it’s just, can we keep him interested? That’s the thing.”
Taylor Sheridan himself has not given a press interview about Lioness since the finale aired. He has not needed to. His track record speaks. Yellowstone got renewed early and often. 1883 and 1923 moved on his timeline. Mayor of Kingstown, Tulsa King, Landman – they all got their orders when he was ready to deliver them.
But there is a new variable. In 2026, Sheridan signed a five-year overall deal with NBCUniversal that starts January 2029. His current Paramount deal runs through 2028. Paramount CEO David Ellison has called him “a singular genius with a perfect track record” and said publicly he wants to keep him. Sheridan’s camp has not signaled an early exit. But the clock is visible now. Every renewal decision carries a subtext it did not have two years ago.
Nicole Kidman, who plays Kaitlyn Meade and produces, has not commented publicly on Season 4. Zoe Saldana, fresh off an Oscar win for Emilia Perez, has not either. Their silence is not unusual for this franchise. The show runs on Sheridan’s schedule, not a publicity calendar.
#
The numbers do not lie
Season 3 finale viewership set a new franchise high on Paramount Plus. The season held an 88 percent critic score and a 77 percent audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. Collider reported that Lioness remained one of the most-watched titles on the service globally more than a month after the finale. In streaming economics, that is the metric that matters. Subscriber retention. Top-of-feed placement. Watercooler conversation that drives trial signups.
Paramount Plus does not release raw numbers. But the trades have sources. The language is consistent “record-breaking,” “franchise high,” “global top tier.” A show that grows its audience in Season 3 after a two-year hiatus is not a show a streamer lets sit.
#
The Sheridan factor
No Taylor Sheridan show has run longer than five seasons. Yellowstone will end at five (or six, depending on how you count the final batch). 1883 was a closed chapter. 1923 is heading toward its planned conclusion. Lioness is the only pure ongoing series in his Paramount stable that has not hit a predetermined endpoint.
Sheridan writes fast. He produces fast. He has three other shows in active production for Paramount Plus right now. The bottleneck has never been his output. It has been the corporate calendar.
The NBCUniversal deal means Paramount knows the window is finite. That can work two ways. They lock in renewals now to maximize the asset while they have it. Or they let decisions drift because the long-term upside belongs to someone else. So far, the drift is winning.
#
Our call
Lean Renewed. Odds 75/25.
The viewership is real. The critical reception is real. The cliffhanger demands resolution. Jill Wagner’s $100 bet is the kind of confidence that usually comes from knowing something the press does not. The only reason this drags is the Sheridan contract timeline – and even that argues for an announcement sooner rather than later. Paramount wants the next season in the can before 2029.
What would change our mind A Sheridan quote saying he’s done with the character. A Paramount Plus earnings call where Lioness is not mentioned. A casting notice for Saldana or Kidman that conflicts with a 2027 production window.
Until then, the silence is just noise. The show is too big to cancel and too valuable to stall.
What do you think – does the Sheridan NBCUniversal deal make a Season 4 more likely or less?