Our Review

Is The Agency Worth Watching? — Honest Take

The Hook: The Bureau (French masterpiece Le Bureau des Légendes) gets an American remake with Michael Fassbender, Jeffrey Wright, and Richard Gere. CIA deep-cover operations, moral rot, and the cost of lying for a living. Showrunner: Joe Wright (not the director — the writer, The Crown S3-4).

What Actually Works:

• Fassbender’s stillness. He plays Martian (codename), a NOC (non-official cover) operative recalled from 6 years in Syria. The performance is in what he doesn’t do: no exposition dumps, no “previously on” face. Episode 2’s 4-minute wordless sequence — him re-entering his London flat, checking sightlines, reheating coffee, sitting in darkness — conveys more about deep-cover psychology than any monologue.
• The “station” as pressure cooker. The London CIA station feels lived-in: stale coffee, carpet stains, the hum of servers. Jeffrey Wright’s station chief (Henry Ogletree) runs it like a tired principal — bureaucratic triage, not spy glamour. Episode 4’s budget meeting (redacting receipts for a dead asset’s funeral) is funnier and sadder than any action beat.
• Richard Gere as the ghost. He plays Martian’s former handler, now retired, dying, and still running an unauthorized op. Their scenes (Ep 3, Ep 6, Ep 8) are the show’s spine — two generations of spies who’ve forgotten how to be human.
• London as a character. Not tourist London. The Barbican at 3 AM. A Hendon safehouse with damp walls. The Thames at low tide. Cinematography by Adriano Goldman (The Crown) — muted, winter, beautiful in a way that hurts.

Where It Stumbles:

• The “Americanization” shows in dialogue. The Bureau trusted silence; The Agency adds exposition. Episode 1’s briefing scene explains NOC protocol that the French version conveyed in a glance. It doesn’t trust the viewer — or the network didn’t.
• Subplot: Martian’s daughter (Ep 5-6). Introduced late, written thin. Her “I Googled you” confrontation feels like a network note: “give him personal stakes.” The actress tries; the material doesn’t meet her.
• Pacing drag in Episodes 4-5. The mole hunt stalls. Two episodes of “who leaked the file” when the answer is obvious from Ep 2. The Bureau spread this across a season; here it’s compressed and loses tension.

Verdict: 8/10. The best spy show on TV since The Americans — flawed by network anxiety but elevated by Fassbender, Wright, Gere, and Goldman’s lens. If you’ve seen The Bureau, watch for the performances. If you haven’t, this stands alone — but seek out the original after.

Watch If: You want spycraft without gadgets; moral ambiguity > good guys/bad guys; you’ll take 10 minutes of a man making coffee over a car chase.
Skip If: You need Jack Ryan energy; exposition dumps irritate you; you’ve seen The Bureau and can’t tolerate a lesser version.

Streaming: Paramount+ / Showtime (Nov 29, 2024 — 10 episodes, weekly)

Last reviewed: November 11, 2026 — JS

—